Why the Nikkei and TOPIX Tell Different Stories — Reading the News Through How Each Index Is Built
In stock market news, you sometimes see a day when the Nikkei rises while TOPIX falls. In the same market, why do the two indices give different impressions? The reason lies in how each index is built. The Nikkei averages the prices of 225 stocks, while TOPIX reflects the whole Tokyo Stock Exchange market by market capitalisation. The calculation method, the stocks covered and the weighting all differ. This article explains the difference in how the two indices are made, and how to use each when reading the news.
In stock market news, you sometimes see a day when the Nikkei rises while TOPIX falls. In the same market, why do the two indices give different impressions? The reason lies in how each index is built. The Nikkei averages the prices of 225 stocks, while TOPIX reflects the whole Tokyo Stock Exchange market by market capitalisation. The calculation method, the stocks covered and the weighting all differ. This article explains the difference in how the two indices are made, and how to use each when reading the news.
The Nikkei — an average of 225 stock prices
The Nikkei 225 is calculated from 225 stocks chosen from those listed on the Tokyo Stock Exchange Prime Market, and is published by Nikkei Inc. The 225 stocks are chosen with liquidity and the balance across industries in mind, and are reviewed regularly. It is the index most often cited in the news as the representative index of the Japanese stock market.
The Nikkei is calculated as a price average. The prices of the 225 stocks are added together and divided by a figure called the divisor. The divisor is adjusted so that the index remains continuous despite stock splits and changes in the constituent stocks. The distinctive feature of this method is that movements in high-priced stocks — so-called high-value stocks — have a large effect on the whole index. If a high-priced stock moves sharply, the index moves sharply even if the other stocks barely move.
The Nikkei has a long history, with calculation beginning in 1950. Its level has changed greatly along with the course of the post-war Japanese economy. It reached its all-time high at the end of 1989, went through a long period of weakness, and in recent years has traded at high levels again. When the level of the Nikkei is discussed, the history of the Japanese economy is layered into it.
TOPIX — market-wide, weighted by market capitalisation
TOPIX (the Tokyo Stock Price Index) reflects the movements of all stocks listed on the Tokyo Stock Exchange Prime Market, and is published by Japan Exchange Group. It is calculated as a market-capitalisation-weighted index. It is based on the total market capitalisation of each stock — the share price multiplied by the number of shares outstanding. Stocks with larger market capitalisation have a larger influence on the index.
TOPIX is distinctive in covering the market broadly. Where the Nikkei is narrowed to 225 stocks, TOPIX covers all stocks on the Prime Market. When you want to know how the market as a whole is moving, TOPIX is the better fit. It is less swayed by a handful of stocks or a single large stock, and it is said to reflect the tone of the market as a whole more easily.
TOPIX is based on 4 January 1968, with the total market capitalisation of that day set at 100. Where the Nikkei is a simple average of prices, TOPIX compares the total market capitalisation with a base value. That difference in calculation is what produces the difference in how the two indices move.
How the calculation difference changes the impression
The Nikkei and TOPIX diverge because of the difference in calculation. The Nikkei is a price average, so movements in high-priced stocks are reflected strongly in the index. For example, if a high-priced stock rises sharply, the Nikkei rises even if the other stocks are flat. Conversely, if a high-priced stock falls sharply, the Nikkei can fall even when the other stocks are rising.
TOPIX is weighted by market capitalisation, so movements in stocks with large market capitalisation are reflected strongly in the index. Stocks with large market capitalisation are large companies with many shares outstanding. When large stocks move, TOPIX moves too, but its structure makes it less affected by a handful of stocks than the Nikkei. Its role is to show how the total market capitalisation of the whole market has changed.
Understanding this difference changes the impression the news gives. A day when the Nikkei rises while TOPIX falls can be read as a day when a few high-priced stocks were bought while selling dominated the market as a whole. Conversely, a day when the Nikkei falls while TOPIX rises can be read as a day when high-priced stocks were sold while buying dominated the market as a whole. Looking at the two indices side by side reveals the composition of market movements.
- Nikkei: an average of 225 stock prices; high-priced stocks have a large influence
- TOPIX: weighted by the market capitalisation of the whole market; large-capitalisation stocks have a large influence
- Days when the two indices diverge are a clue to the composition of the market
Differences in the stocks chosen and replaced
The Nikkei and TOPIX also differ in how their constituent stocks are decided. The 225 stocks of the Nikkei are chosen by Nikkei Inc. with liquidity and the balance across industries in mind, and are reviewed regularly. Care is taken to choose stocks in a balanced way across industries, so that the index is not skewed toward one industry. Stocks are replaced in an annual regular review, and also on an ad-hoc basis when mergers or delistings require it.
TOPIX covers all stocks listed on the Prime Market. Stocks are added or removed in line with changes in market segment or delistings. Rather than selecting stocks as the Nikkei does, TOPIX reflects the whole market as it is. Its constituents are far more numerous than the Nikkei's, and its industry mix reflects the market as a whole.
The difference in the stocks chosen also leads to differences in industry mix. In the Nikkei, the influence of the industries to which high-priced stocks belong tends to grow; in TOPIX, the influence of industries with large market capitalisation grows. When thinking about how industry movements are reflected in an index, it is important to know this difference.
Which index should you look at?
Which of the Nikkei and TOPIX to look at depends on what you want to know. When you want to know the movements of large stocks that represent Japan, or a quick impression of the market as a news headline, the Nikkei fits. It is the index most often cited in the news, and it is used as an indicator for grasping the mood of the market quickly.
When you want to know how the market as a whole is moving, or the tone of the market where most of the stocks you hold are listed, TOPIX fits. Because TOPIX covers the market broadly, it is less swayed by a handful of stocks and easier to use for grasping the trend of the market as a whole. Above all, if you invest across a wide range of stocks, the movement of TOPIX can be close to the movement of your own assets.
In practice, it is important to look at both side by side rather than only one. If the two indices move in the same direction, the direction of the market as a whole is clear. If the two indices diverge, it is a prompt to think one step further about what is happening inside the market. The difference between the indices is a tool for widening how you see the market.
The choice of index also changes with investment style. People who invest in individual stocks may find the Nikkei's movement close to the movement of their own stocks. People who invest across a wide range of stocks may find TOPIX's movement close to the movement of their own assets. It is also worth choosing the index to watch in line with your own investment style.
Points to keep in mind when reading an index
One point to keep in mind when reading an index is that an index is an average, and it is different from the movement of any individual stock. Even if the Nikkei rises, the stocks you hold do not necessarily rise. Even if TOPIX falls, some stocks are rising. An index compresses the shape of the whole market into a single number; it does not guarantee the movement of any individual stock.
Another point is that the level of an index alone cannot tell you whether the market is cheap or expensive. The level of an index only has meaning in comparison with the past, and in comparison with corporate earnings. Looking at it together with indicators such as the PER (price-earnings ratio) shows how the index level stands against corporate earnings. Judging high or low from the index number alone should be avoided.
The influence of exchange rates and overseas markets also needs to be considered. The Nikkei and TOPIX are affected by overseas factors such as the yen's exchange rate and movements in the US market. When thinking about why an index moved, it is important to look at exchange rates and overseas markets together with domestic factors.
The influence of exchange rates on the Nikkei and TOPIX should not be overlooked. When the yen weakens, the view that exporters' earnings will grow can push share prices up. Conversely, when the yen strengthens, the view that exporters' earnings will shrink can push share prices down. When thinking about why an index moved, it is important to look at exchange rate movements as well. The relationship between exchange rates and share prices changes with the market's focus at the time, so it cannot be fixed to a single view.
Comparing the long-term movements of the Nikkei and TOPIX
Comparing the long-term movements of the Nikkei and TOPIX, the two have generally moved in the same direction. Both rose during Japan's growth years, and both fell after the collapse of the bubble. Over the long term, the movements of the two indices look much alike. The differences stand out in short-term movements, or when particular stocks move sharply.
The reason the long-term movements are similar is that both reflect the Japanese stock market. When the trend of the market as a whole changes, both indices move in the same direction. The difference between the two indices appears not in the long-term trend, but in how they swing in the short term and how they reflect the composition of the market. From the viewpoint of long-term investment, there is little difference in which index you watch.
That the long-term movements of the two indices are similar is also a reference for choosing an index. If you want to know the long-term trend of the market, there is little difference between the two. If you want to know short-term movements or the composition of the market, the difference between the two indices is a useful clue. How you use the indices changes with the time horizon you want to know about.
TOPIX and industry indices
TOPIX also has industry indices. The TOPIX industry indices are calculated for 33 industries, and they are a clue to which industries are leading the market. For example, if the automobile or electronics industries rise, TOPIX as a whole tends to rise. Looking at industry indices shows the composition of the market's movements in more detail.
The Nikkei, too, has a design that reflects industry movements. Its constituents are chosen with the balance across industries in mind, so its structure is hard to skew toward a single industry. Even so, the influence of the industries to which high-priced stocks belong tends to grow. When you want to know how industries are moving, the TOPIX industry indices are the better fit.
Getting into the habit of looking at industry indices changes how you read the news. When you see news that the Nikkei rose, check with the industry indices which industries rose. Then the background of the market's movement comes into view more concretely. An index is a tool not only for the number of the market as a whole, but also for knowing its composition.
Indices and investment trusts and ETFs
The Nikkei and TOPIX are also used as benchmarks for investment trusts and ETFs. Investment trusts and ETFs linked to the Nikkei are managed so that they track the movement of the Nikkei. The same holds for products linked to TOPIX. Through index-linked products, individual investors have come to engage directly with the movement of the indices.
As index-linked products have grown, the influence of index movements on the market as a whole has also grown. When the money linked to an index grows, the flow of money into the index's constituent stocks grows too. An index is a mirror reflecting the movement of the market, and at the same time a standard that decides the flow of money.
In summary — knowing how an index is built changes the news
The Nikkei and TOPIX both reflect the Japanese stock market, but they are built differently. The Nikkei is an average of 225 stock prices, and it is easily affected by high-priced stocks. TOPIX is weighted by the market capitalisation of the whole market, and it easily reflects the movement of the market as a whole. Knowing this difference lets you read the meaning of days when the two indices diverge.
When you see an index number in the news, try to be aware of what that number reflects. Does the movement of the Nikkei reflect the movement of representative large stocks? Does the movement of TOPIX reflect the tone of the market as a whole? Knowing how an index is built is the first step to thinking about market movements with your own head, rather than being swayed by the impression of the news. This article is a general explanation of how indices work, and is not investment advice.
Related Terms
GLOSSARYRelated Articles
RELATEDHow to Read Japan's Tax Reform Outline — What December's Draft Proposals Mean for Next Year's Taxes on Households and Companies
Every December, the ruling parties' tax research councils compile the tax reform outline. How do the proposed revisions to income, corporate and asset taxes reach households and companies? This article explains how to read the outline as a proposal rather than a decision, and how to check outline news when you meet it.
Reading the Shunto — How Wage-Increase News Is Made, and How It Spreads
The shunto, or spring labor offensive, fills the news every spring. This article explains the sequence of demands, negotiations, the concentrated response day and settlements, the channels through which increases spread from large firms to smaller ones, and how to read the published figures.
Reading Household Finances Through Real Wages — What the Gap Between Nominal Pay and Prices Reveals About Daily Life
Why does life not feel easier even when nominal wages rise? This article explains how real wages and the Consumer Price Index (CPI) work, how the spring wage negotiations (shunto) and the minimum wage reach households, why statistical averages differ from what people feel, and how to review household spending while prices rise. The habit of thinking in real terms helps you read the news in relation to your own household.