Who Was 24-Hour Operation For? Late Nights, Franchising, and the Turning Point for Convenience Stores
Late at night, a convenience store's bright lights feel like a permanent part of the streetscape. Yet behind that light lies a franchise contract, labour costs, and a gap between headquarters and owners that the labour shortage is widening.
The Light That Stays On All Night
Walk through a city late at night and, among shuttered shops, the bright lights of a convenience store stand out. Being able to buy food and drink at any hour has become an ordinary part of daily life. Yet behind that light, a long-running debate continues: who keeps the store running, who earns the profit, and who bears the burden?
At the centre of that debate is 24-hour operation. For customers it is convenient, but for those who run the store it means higher labour and utility costs. Late at night, when few customers visit, balancing sales against costs becomes especially difficult. Without understanding the cost structure behind the convenience, the full picture remains out of reach.
This article reads the debate over 24-hour operation through two lenses: the labour shortage and the franchise system. It traces how franchise contracts work, how headquarters and store owners relate, why around-the-clock opening became the norm, and how the labour shortage changed the calculation, before asking where the industry's turning point lies.
How the Franchise System Works
Most convenience stores in Japan are run under a franchise system. A headquarters, which owns the brand, the supply network and the operating know-how, signs a contract with an owner who runs an individual store. The owner trades under the headquarters' name and uses its systems, while paying a share of profit back as a royalty.
The system divides roles: the owner carries the business risk and the day-to-day operation, while the headquarters handles planning for the brand as a whole, logistics and product development. As the person responsible for the store, the owner takes on hiring, shift management, ordering and cleaning.
Franchising was an effective way to spread many stores across the country in a short time. Headquarters could expand without funding every opening itself, and owners could start an independent business under a well-known brand. The model took hold because it offered advantages to both sides.
Royalties and How Profit Is Shared
In a franchise contract, how the royalty is set matters a great deal. In general, convenience-store royalties are based not on sales themselves but on gross profit — sales minus the cost of the goods sold. The royalty burden therefore moves in step with how much profit the store generates.
What deserves attention is that labour, utility and rent costs are not deducted before the royalty is calculated. When a store stays open through the night, the cost of staffing those hours falls mainly on the owner, and it is not directly reflected in the royalty calculation.
This structure is essential to understanding the 24-hour debate, because headquarters and owners see late-night trading differently. For headquarters, late-night sales add to the brand's overall sales; for the owner, late-night labour costs eat directly into the profit left in hand. The same late night looks different depending on where one stands.
Why 24-Hour Operation Became the Norm
When convenience stores first began trading around the clock, it was a way to stand out from other shops. For people working late, travelling at night, or needing an urgent purchase, a store that was always open held real value. Competitors soon followed, and 24-hour operation became the standard for the whole industry.
Staying open all night also carried meaning beyond sales. A store lit through the night strengthened trust in the brand and a sense of presence, which was thought to encourage visits during the day as well. The light itself acted as advertising, fixing the store's location in people's minds.
Round-the-clock opening also suited logistics and stocking. Goods could be delivered and shelves filled overnight, so the store was ready when morning came. Without a closing time, back-of-house work could be arranged more flexibly. These reasons together made 24-hour operation feel like the natural state of things for a long time.
Late-Night Sales and Late-Night Costs
Any discussion of 24-hour operation must face the balance sheet of the late-night hours. Fewer customers visit after midnight than during the day, and the average spend per visit tends not to be large. Meanwhile, keeping the store open means paying late-night wage premiums and running lights and refrigeration without pause.
Taken on its own, late-night trading can therefore struggle to cover its costs. Of course, late-night sales also carry less visible effects, such as encouraging daytime visits and supporting the brand's overall value. But for an owner facing daily accounts, a late-night loss is a direct weight on the business.
There was a time when late-night labour was comparatively inexpensive and staff for the night shift were easier to find. In that era, the cost of staying open through the night stayed within a tolerable range. As wage and price levels changed, however, the balance of the late-night hours gradually became tighter.
How the Labour Shortage Changed the Calculation
In recent years, the labour shortage has become serious across many industries, and convenience stores are no exception. Staffing the late-night hours has become especially difficult. Night work places a heavy burden on daily rhythms, so it is easily avoided by job seekers, and recruitment can attract few applicants.
When no staff can be found, the owner often has to cover the night shift personally. Standing in the store through the night is a heavy physical and mental burden, cutting into rest and time with family. Such voices from the shop floor lie behind the calls to reconsider 24-hour operation.
The shortage goes beyond hiring. In a short-staffed store, it becomes harder to maintain service quality, the range of goods on the shelves, and cleanliness. Keeping the store open around the clock can itself become a reason for quality to slip — a paradox in which the system meant to protect convenience adds to the burden on the shop floor.
Rising Minimum Wages and Night Labour Costs
Alongside the labour shortage, rising minimum wages have changed the calculation behind 24-hour operation. When the minimum wage rises, so do the wages of those working at night. Because night work carries a wage premium, late-night labour costs are higher than daytime costs, so a rise in the minimum wage feeds directly into the cost of staying open overnight.
Higher wages are welcome for workers. From the store's point of view, however, costs rise without sales rising to match. If late-night sales remain weak while labour costs climb, the balance of the night hours becomes still harder to sustain. Readers may also wish to see the glossary entry on the minimum wage.
This is not a problem for convenience stores alone. Restaurants, retailers and many other industries face the same challenge. But because 24-hour operation is the premise of the convenience-store model, the format is especially exposed to wage changes. A shift in wage levels across society has become a prompt to rethink what the late-night light should look like.
Headquarters and Owners See It Differently
One reason the debate drags on is the difference in position between headquarters and owners. For headquarters, keeping stores open around the clock is often seen as essential to protecting brand value and sustaining overall sales. The presence of the chain as a whole can matter more than the late-night loss of a single store.
For the owner, by contrast, the accounts of one store are everything. If late-night sales cannot cover labour costs, the loss presses directly on that owner's business. An explanation in terms of brand value alone does not lighten the burden on the shop floor. The same 24 hours look like a different landscape from each side.
The difference also touches the contract itself. Who holds the power to decide opening hours, and on what terms can late-night trading be stopped? Such contractual terms shape where the debate leads. The franchise system itself forms the ground on which the 24-hour question is argued.
Shorter Hours as an Option
Against this background, shortening opening hours, or closing at night, has become a realistic option. What was once seen as an exceptional response is now increasingly treated as one option to be considered according to the region and the circumstances of each store.
Shorter hours offer more than savings on late-night labour and utilities. When owners and staff get proper rest, the quality of daytime service can improve and the store as a whole can run more stably. The thinking is that raising the quality of the hours the store is open may protect its value better, over the long term, than forcing it to stay open.
Shorter hours also bring challenges, of course. People who used the store at night lose convenience, and customers may drift to nearby shops. There are also concerns about safety when the lights go out at night. Shorter hours are a choice about where to strike a balance between convenience and sustainability.
The Convenience Store Beyond the Turning Point
The debate over 24-hour operation is not only about whether to open at night. It asks who gains the profit and who bears the burden within the franchise system, and what forms of work and management can endure in an era of labour shortage and rising wages.
The industry's turning point may lie in moving from uniform 24-hour operation toward hours fitted to the circumstances of each place and store. Where late-night demand is strong, stores could stay open around the clock; where it is weak, they could shorten their hours. Such flexibility could produce an arrangement both headquarters and owners can accept.
The lights of convenience stores will surely go on being needed in towns and cities. But the question of whose burden, and under what system, keeps those lights on is now one the whole industry must answer. The turning point for 24-hour operation is also a turning point for the convenience-store format itself.
Related Terms
GLOSSARYRelated Articles
RELATEDFares Alone Don't Pay — How Railway Companies Earn from the 'Along-the-Line' Business
Japanese private railways earn not only from fares but from housing, shops, hotels and leisure along their lines. We explain the 'along-the-line' business model and how to read it in financial statements.
Beyond Bigger Dividends and Buybacks — Reading Shareholder Returns Through Where the Cash Actually Goes
News of dividend increases and share buybacks keeps coming. This article explains the mechanics of dividends and buybacks, the cash flow that funds returns, and the Tokyo Stock Exchange request and the PBR story behind them — and how to avoid judging a company by the size of its returns alone.
Dividends and Share Buybacks — The Basics of Reading 'Shareholder Returns' News
Higher dividends, buybacks, payout ratios and total return ratios. This guide explains the terms that fill earnings-season headlines, why companies are increasing returns, and which figures to read together.